One of the most viewed posts on my blog is the one about Rimi Sen's "black African" comment. Personally, after saying my piece, I was quite prepared to let the whole thing die. I mean, it's not like she threatened to put a pitch fork up anyone's hindparts or anything. Four months later in a new year, that post is once again getting hits [Hello black Britain!] so I figure it's way past time to collect and spew my thoughts.
Initially, I intended to do a multi-paragraph pondering on the semantics of "dark" versus "black." In one sense, dark is a more likely accurate description of someone than saying that person is black because they most likely aren't. Then again, dark is merely comparative--it can only be understood in relationship to its opposite--whereas black is definitive.
So then, to say that you are black is to define yourself. Say it loud! I'm black and I'm proud! To say that you are dark is much more elusive. It establishes "otherness" without affiliation. (I guess this is where brownz comes in?)
So back to my post on Rimi. There was one comment that reminded me once again that "Who is black?" a neverending question with many possible answers.
I've never met or seen a "black African" that looks remotely like Beyonce, Halle Berry or Rihanna.
That's probably because those girls are
black but not African!
[FYI, Halle's mother is white and Rihanna is from Barbados. Her father is half white.] That leads to the question, "
Does black = African?" Not necessarily but
black is always a derivative of Africa, much the same way that high fructose corn syrup is
all natural. ;) This leads to a second anonymous "
gem":
The so called American Blacks like Beyonce and others are not like black Africans at all.
While I realize it's probably not the best use of mental resources to even bother with this, I'm always up for providing an educational moment. Of course there are tremendous differences between black Americans and residents of the Mother Continent! American life has ruined many a person for life anywhere else.
If I wanted to be all deep and break it down to minutia, I would give a detailed explanation of the
Transatlantic slave trade that brought hundreds of thousands of
West Africans of to the US and tell you which countries they came from then go into tribal affiliations but anyone who was really curious about that would already know
something about it.
So what are we talking about here? The way people look? It's no secret that many black Americans aren't even close to being fully African in ancestry.
About 30% of black Americans who take DNA tests to determine their African lineage prove to be descended from Europeans on their father's side. [ref] It's quite likely that Beyonce and Lord knows
Harold "
light, bright, darn near white"
Ford, Jr. are in that camp. And we're not just talking a single white ancestor.
While taping the documentary,
African American Lives, Harvard University's chair of African American studies,
Henry Louis Gates, Jr. discovered that his DNA was sourced as 50% European! Music Producer
Quincy Jones is 34% European. Do either of them look European to you?
On the other hand,
Oprah Winfrey is 89% sub-Saharan African and
Whoopi Goldberg 92%. Is that what you think of when you hear the word "African"? Who among the two camps reserves the right to be called "black"?
Or are we decrying a difference in culture? I don't care what your background is when you get here, I'll bet money your great-great grandkids' lifestyles won't be much other than
American with a twist. That being the case, what can we realistically expect from families that have been in the U.S. for 15 generations or more while
unable to reconnect with their ancestral land?
As for Ms. Sen, she leaves a few questions lingering in my mind: Did she mean to say that
black people are ugly? African people are ugly? Dark/black-skinned people are ugly? As for commenters on the fascinatingly unique situation of the "black American," I hope this post offers some food for thought.
Okay, I'm all blogged out.
I'd love to hear everyone else's thoughts!FYI: Today's post title is brought to you by the Song of Solomon chapter 1, verse 5! [ref]